Bank Deposits and Risk Perception of Depositors

Bank deposits and risk perception of depositors

As banks have risk assessment for deploying their resources, depositors have their own perception of risk about banks for depositing their savings and to that extent the financial literacy can be considered to be very high and the awareness about market risk is appreciable. This is evident from the position of deposits of various bank groups in India during the period 2008- 2010 ie the beginning of crisis during the crisis and afterwards. The global financial crisis which triggered in September 2008 in US market and subsequently spread all over the world has impacted the Indian banking in several ways although it remained insulated from the severe jolt experienced by its counterparts particularly in advanced countries. The bank group wise figures illustrates that the confidence level of public in private sector banks including foreign banks has witnessed a set back and it has increased considerably in public sector banks during the crisis period. Depositors seem to have perceived more risk in depositing their money with private sector banks and shifted their loyalty to public sector banks as revealed by the figures.

Public confidence in banks depends basically on ownership, sound regulatory and supervisory system in force and insurance coverage for their deposits. They also worry about the inflation risk and they have their calculation on real interest and hedge against this risk. As the insurance coverage for deposits is limited to only Rs 1 lakh per depositor irrespective of the bank (whether private or public) in which the deposit is made, the preference of public for safety of their entire deposits with public sector banks is understandable and is fully justifiable during a crisis period like the one the world experienced since September 2008. Although the Indian banks are well run and financially sound because of efficient and effective regulatory and supervisory mechanism, the preference for public sector by depositors is apparent and well exhibited as revealed by various parameters. For instance, the share of public sector banks in total deposits which stood at 73.91 percent before the crisis ie as at end March 2008, increased to77.61percent as at end March 2009 ie during the crisis and further to 77.68 percent as at end March 2010 after recovery began. The following table will indicate share of deposits to total deposits and rate of growth of deposits in different bank Groups during 2008-10.

Bank groups 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10
Share of deposits to Total deposits Rate of growth of deposits Share of deposits to Total deposits Rate of growth of deposits Share of deposits to Total deposits Rate of growth of deposits
Public Sector Banks 73.91% 23.05% 76.61% 26.85% 77.68% 18.60%
Old Private Sector Banks 4.99% 19.78% 4.90% 20.34% 4.84% 15.37%
New Private Banks 15.34% 23.13% 13.22% 5.43% 12.48% 10.39%
Foreign Banks 5.76% 26.81% 5.27% 11.99% 5.00% 11.11%

The rate of growth of deposits in general has registered a sharp decline in all bank groups as at end March 2010 as compare to that of end march 2008 perhaps evidencing increased awareness among public to hedge against inflation. While the inflation rate has been on the increase for the past couple of years, the rate of interest has fallen leaving no incentive to save money with the banks. High inflation adversely affects the capacity and propensity to save. In the absence of any real rate of interest, the public seem to have opted to spend more, save less and invest available surplus in alternative assets or instruments such as gold, real estate and other instruments of savings which fetch offer better return than banks. The increase in real estate, commodity prices (particularly gold and silver) and sensex which has recently crossed 20K is a clear indication that public awareness about investment market has gone up and their risk perception, risk assessment and risk management have improved well .

While the share of old private sector banks and foreign banks in total deposits showed a marginal decline during the period 2008 -10, the share of new private sector banks declined considerably from 15.34 percent in 2008 to 12.48 percent in 2010. The rate of fall in deposit during the crisis year ie 2009 is significant in new private sector and foreign banks as compared to other bank groups.

While the investors awareness about market risks and alternative avenues of investments is welcome, the risks they carry on speculative investments in gold and real estates are something of very high order. The markets and the economy also carry heavy risk from this sort of build- up of assets in the long run and need to be taken care of.

Dr.T.V.Gopalakrishnan

(This appeared in Business Line dt4/10/2010)